Alan Shearer gives Newcastle Star a rating of 4/10 for his performance against Benfica despite victory

Newcastle United legend Alan Shearer has expressed mixed feelings following the club’s hard-fought victory over Benfica in a recent European clash. Despite the win, Shearer was far from impressed with the performance of one particular Newcastle star, handing him a rating of 4/10 for what he described as a “disappointing and unconvincing display.”

Newcastle managed to edge out Benfica with a 2-1 victory at St. James’ Park, thanks to goals from Alexander Isak and Anthony Gordon, but Shearer’s post-match analysis focused on the individual struggles of Miguel Almirón, who failed to influence the game as expected. According to Shearer, the Paraguayan winger looked “off the pace,” lacked creativity, and repeatedly lost possession in crucial areas.

“Shearer told BBC Match of the Day: ‘You can’t question his effort — he always runs and tries — but this time, it just wasn’t enough. His decision-making was poor, and his end product was missing. On a night when Newcastle needed sharpness and composure, he looked out of ideas. For me, that’s a 4/10 performance.’”

Fans online were divided over Shearer’s rating. Some agreed that Almirón’s form has dipped in recent weeks, while others felt the criticism was too harsh given the team’s overall success. The winger, who has been a loyal and hardworking player under Eddie Howe, struggled to create meaningful chances despite Newcastle’s attacking dominance for much of the game.

While Shearer praised the collective effort and resilience of the Magpies, he emphasized that Newcastle must demand higher individual standards if they are to compete consistently in Europe. “Winning is great, but consistency from key players will determine how far this team goes,” Shearer added.

While Shearer praised the collective effort and resilience of the Magpies, he emphasized that Newcastle must demand higher individual standards if they are to compete consistently in Europe. “Winning is great, but consistency from key players will determine how far this team goes,” Shearer added.