Everton supporters have made their voices loud and clear after another frustrating performance that has left many questioning David Moyes’ tactical decisions. The growing sentiment among fans is that one of Everton’s most talented players is being deployed out of position, which is limiting both his impact and the team’s overall attacking potential.
Social media platforms have been buzzing with discussions, particularly around the use of Dwight McNeil, who many believe is being wasted in a deeper or more defensive role under Moyes. Traditionally known for his pace, creativity, and ability to cut inside from the wing, McNeil has often been seen tracking back and defending rather than doing what he does best — creating and scoring chances. Supporters argue that Moyes’ cautious style and rigid formation are stifling the natural flair and attacking instincts of players like McNeil, who thrive when given freedom on the ball.
Several fans took to X (formerly Twitter) to express their frustration, with one writing, “Moyes needs to stop playing McNeil like a full-back. He’s a winger, not a defender!” Another added, “It’s painful watching him so deep; he should be higher up the pitch linking with Calvert-Lewin.”
While Moyes has brought discipline and structure to Everton since returning to Goodison Park, critics feel his defensive mindset has come at the expense of creativity. The team has struggled for goals in recent matches, and fans believe a simple positional adjustment could spark a turnaround.
Everton’s upcoming fixtures will be crucial, and all eyes will be on Moyes to see if he listens to the growing calls for change. With the Toffees needing every point to climb the table, playing key talents like McNeil in their natural roles could be the key to unlocking Everton’s attacking potential and restoring confidence among the fanbase.
One thing is certain — Everton fans are demanding an urgent tactical rethink before it’s too late.