“Marc Guehi tells it like it is – and we’re all thinking the same thing!”

Jamie Carragher, a Sky Sports pundit, has expressed his thoughts on Crystal Palace’s Marc Guehi, stating that while he’s a “good player,” he wouldn’t pay £70m for him. This sentiment is shared by some Newcastle fans, who question whether Guehi is worth a club-record fee, especially considering the team’s need for a right-winger.

Carragher’s comments highlight the dilemma Newcastle faces in their pursuit of Guehi. With Botman’s injury leaving a gap in the defense, the pressure is on to secure a quality replacement. However, the proposed fee for Guehi raises questions about whether there are better value options available.

Newcastle’s transfer budget is limited, and allocating a significant portion to Guehi might mean sacrificing the opportunity to sign a much-needed right-winger. Carragher’s suggestion that the club might find someone cheaper elsewhere is a valid concern. The comparison to previous transfers, such as Sven Botman and Bruno Guimaraes, who were signed for significantly lower fees, adds to the debate.

The hypothetical scenario of signing AC Milan’s Malick Thiaw for half the price of Guehi and using the remaining funds to bring in a quality right-winger is an intriguing alternative. This approach would address the team’s defensive needs while also bolstering the attack.

Carragher’s comments have sparked a valuable discussion about Newcastle’s transfer strategy and the importance of finding the right balance in the team’s squad. While Guehi is a talented player, the question remains whether he’s worth the hefty price tag. As the transfer window progresses, Newcastle must weigh their options carefully to ensure they make the most of their budget.

In conclusion, the debate surrounding Guehi’s transfer fee highlights the complexities of the transfer market. Newcastle must consider their priorities and budget constraints to make an informed decision. While Guehi is a good player, the question remains whether he’s worth the club-record fee. The hypothetical scenario of signing Thiaw and a right-winger presents an attractive alternative, and Newcastle must carefully evaluate their options to strengthen their squad.