# Gary Neville’s Bombshell Statement on Marc Guehi’s Collapsed Liverpool Move Rocks Reds Fanbase
**By Sports Desk | September 2, 2025**
In a stunning turn of events that has sent shockwaves through the football world, Sky Sports pundit Gary Neville has unleashed a scathing critique of Liverpool’s failed deadline-day pursuit of Crystal Palace defender Marc Guehi. The England international’s anticipated £35 million switch to Anfield dramatically fell apart in the final hours of the summer transfer window, leaving fans reeling. But it was Neville’s no-holds-barred comments on his podcast, “The Overlap,” that truly ignited the firestorm, accusing the club’s hierarchy of “amateur-hour negotiations” and questioning their ambition under Arne Slot.
Neville, a former Manchester United captain and long-time rival of Liverpool, didn’t mince words. “This Guehi deal collapsing is emblematic of Liverpool’s transfer woes,” he stated. “You’ve got a player who’s proven himself at Euro 2024, a leader at Palace, and Liverpool dithered like they were shopping in a bargain bin. £35m for a defender of his caliber? That’s a steal in today’s market. But no, they lowballed Palace, dragged their feet on personal terms, and now they’re left with Virgil van Dijk carrying the backline on his aging shoulders. If Slot wants to challenge for the title, this kind of incompetence from the boardroom will cost them dearly. Fans should be furious – this isn’t the Liverpool of old; it’s a club that’s lost its edge.”
The statement, released just hours after the window slammed shut on August 31, has divided the Liverpool faithful. Social media erupted with a mix of outrage and agreement. On X (formerly Twitter), the hashtag #NevilleOut trended as some supporters lambasted the pundit for “stirring the pot” from his United bias. “Gary Neville talking about Liverpool’s ambition? The irony from a man whose club is in freefall,” tweeted one fan. Others, however, echoed his sentiments, pointing to the Reds’ quiet window – with only minor signings like Federico Chiesa – as evidence of stagnation. “Neville’s spot on. We’ve got the money from sales, yet we couldn’t close Guehi? FSG out!” read another post, referencing owners Fenway Sports Group.
Background on the saga reveals a protracted negotiation battle. Guehi, 25, had been earmarked as van Dijk’s long-term successor, with his composure, aerial prowess, and leadership qualities making him a perfect fit for Slot’s system. Palace, however, held firm on their valuation, rejecting multiple bids from Liverpool that reportedly peaked at £30m plus add-ons. Sources close to the deal suggest a last-minute hitch over Guehi’s wage demands and a sell-on clause derailed the move. Crystal Palace chairman Steve Parish later confirmed the collapse, praising Guehi’s loyalty: “Marc’s committed to us, and we’re thrilled he’s staying.”
The fallout has extended beyond fans. Liverpool legend Jamie Carragher, Neville’s Sky colleague, hit back on air, defending the club’s strategy. “Gary’s talking rubbish. We didn’t overpay for a player when we’ve got Jarell Quansah emerging. This isn’t panic buying.” Yet, with Liverpool facing a grueling season in the Premier League, Champions League, and domestic cups, the absence of defensive reinforcements could prove costly. Injuries to key players like Ibrahima Konate have already exposed vulnerabilities.
As the dust settles, Guehi is set to address the media, with reports suggesting he’ll reaffirm his focus on Palace while leaving the door open for a January revisit. For Liverpool fans, Neville’s words have struck a nerve, amplifying frustrations over a window that promised much but delivered little. Whether this sparks a mid-season spending spree or fuels fan protests remains to be seen, but one thing’s clear: the Anfield faithful are shaken, stirred, and demanding answers.