The aftermath of Liverpool’s narrow 2-1 victory over Everton in the Merseyside derby has sparked fresh controversy, with former Premier League referee Keith Hackett once again demanding significant reform to English football’s rulebook. The clash at Anfield was filled with intensity, goals, and contentious officiating decisions that reignited debate about the use of VAR and the application of current laws.
Hackett, who once served as the head of the Professional Game Match Officials Limited (PGMOL), was quick to voice his displeasure over the consistency and clarity of refereeing in the Premier League. In his post-match comments, he suggested that the time had come for a major rule change to protect the flow of the game and restore faith in officiating standards.
Central to Hackett’s argument was the handling of key moments in the match, including a debated penalty call that allowed Liverpool to take the lead. While some supporters argued that the decision was technically correct under existing interpretations, Hackett insisted that the laws are now too rigid, with referees forced into situations where common sense is sacrificed for rulebook precision.
“The laws of the game need updating for the modern era,” Hackett said. “We are seeing too many matches overshadowed by technical interpretations rather than footballing spirit. Referees are under enormous pressure, and VAR, rather than helping, has often made matters worse. A major rule change is required to simplify decision-making and return authority to officials on the pitch.”
His comments have struck a chord with many fans, particularly Everton supporters, who felt aggrieved by the officiating at Anfield. Social media erupted after the match, with rival fans also pointing out that inconsistency in applying rules has plagued the league all season.
Hackett’s call for reform is not new, but his latest intervention adds to growing pressure on the Premier League and IFAB (International Football Association Board) to revisit the laws surrounding handballs, fouls, and VAR protocols. With high-profile managers and players also voicing concerns, the debate over a rule change is unlikely to fade anytime soon.
As the dust settles on another fiery Merseyside derby, Hackett’s comments will fuel discussions not only among fans but also within football’s governing bodies. Whether his proposed changes materialize remains to be seen, but what is clear is that trust in officiating remains one of the Premier League’s biggest challenges.