Newcastle fans have had enough of the star player, calling for him to be dropped after his actions in the Man City vs Newcastle clash. Supporters insist he’ll only keep making the same mistakes.

Newcastle United supporters have reached a breaking point, and the reactions pouring out after the recent clash with Manchester City reveal just how frustrated and exhausted the fanbase has become. For months, they have tried to remain patient, to show loyalty, and to trust that one of their key players would eventually rediscover his rhythm. But after his showing against City, many feel they have run out of reasons—and excuses—to keep defending him. What was once silent concern has now erupted into full-blown disappointment, and from every corner of the fan community, the message is loud, emotional, and impossible to ignore.

One fan summed up the sentiment bluntly: “I honestly can’t keep making explanations for him anymore.” It’s a heavy statement because it comes from a place of prolonged hope. For a long time, supporters believed the player would bounce back, that a single great performance could reignite the fire that made him one of Newcastle’s most trusted figures not too long ago. But as the weeks have passed, and as his form continues to slip deeper into inconsistency, the belief is fading. Many now feel that no matter how much they try to shield him from criticism, his performances speak louder than anyone defending him ever could.

Another supporter expressed an even stronger opinion, insisting that “at the moment, he shouldn’t even be considered for the starting lineup.” This isn’t just typical football anger or emotional exaggeration; it’s a genuine reflection of a fanbase that believes the team’s overall rhythm and tactical structure are being held back. Newcastle are fighting to maintain momentum in a very competitive season, and any weak link—especially in high-stakes matches—becomes a glaring problem. The fans feel that starting him right now isn’t simply a coaching decision; it’s a risk that could continue costing them results, stability, and confidence on the pitch.

Some reactions carry a different kind of pain, not anger but sadness. Supporters have watched this player rise, shine, and once command the respect of the entire league, only to see him struggle now in ways no one expected. “What happened to him? It’s heartbreaking to witness,” a fan wrote, echoing a sentiment shared by many who still appreciate him but can’t deny the decline. They don’t just see a player performing badly; they see someone who looks lost, unsure, and disconnected from the sharpness he once had. It feels like watching a dimming light that used to burn incredibly bright.

Even though Newcastle managed to come away with a victory in the match, the result wasn’t enough to quiet the concerns. Supporters repeatedly emphasized that “there are serious issues that need addressing before the next fixture.” The win, while important, didn’t overshadow the individual mistakes, lapses in concentration, and worrying patterns that keep resurfacing. Fans believe that if these problems aren’t corrected quickly, the team could pay the price in future games, especially against tougher opposition where every error is punished.

The conversation isn’t just about one match—it’s about repeated behaviors. Fans fear the cycle will continue because they’ve seen this same pattern play out too many times: small mistakes turning into bigger ones, promising starts fading into disappointing endings, and moments of brilliance overshadowed by avoidable errors. The narrative is no longer about an occasional off-day; it’s about consistency, accountability, and responsibility.

Throughout social media, group chats, and football forums, Newcastle supporters have made their frustrations unmistakably clear. The tone isn’t mild or uncertain—it’s firm, emotional, and a bit desperate. They care deeply about their club, and that care transforms into passion, which in turn becomes disappointment when a player they once celebrated begins to cost the team more than he contributes.

It’s also worth noting that many fans are not coming from a place of hatred but from deep concern. They want the player to succeed. They want him to regain his spark. Yet they can’t deny the impact his current form is having on the squad. Supporters of Newcastle are known for their loyalty, but they are equally known for their honesty—and right now, honesty means admitting that things cannot continue this way.

Some argue that the coaching staff must intervene decisively: give him a break, reduce his minutes, or allow him time to rebuild his confidence away from the pressure of starting every match. Others think he should be benched until he shows improvement in training. A few believe competition for his position should be increased to push him harder. Regardless of the solution, the collective agreement is that change is necessary.

The emotional storm surrounding this situation isn’t just about disappointment; it’s about fear. Fear that this decline could worsen. Fear that holding onto hope for too long could cost the team vital points. Fear that a once-reliable figure may never return to the level he once commanded.

In the end, the message from the fans is unified: they are exhausted, they are concerned, and they want action. Whether the coaching staff responds or not remains to be seen, but one thing is absolutely clear—Newcastle supporters are no longer willing to stay silent about a problem that keeps repeating itself.

And now, after the latest performance, their voices are louder than ever.